Update: got in contact with Garmin and they sent out a refurbished unit for free! They were a bit surprised that my 235 hadn't even made it past 2 years of use.
Garmin G010-N1685-B4 Fenix 5S Sapphire Goldtone with Black Band Multisport Watch - Certified Refurbished - Deal Parade
Snag Big Discounts on Refurbished Garmin Devices While This Sale Lasts - CNET
Garmin Vivoactive 4 Slate with Black Band - Factory Ref
Garmin RV 890 - Refurbished – TechnoRV
Garmin G010-n1685-b4 Fenix 5s Sapphire Goldtone With Black Band Multisport Watch - Certified Refurbished : Target
Restored Garmin vivoactive 4 Black with Slate Hardware Multisport GPS Watch, Built-in GPS (Refurbished) - Walmart.com
Refurbished Garmin Forerunner 25 black and Red GPS Running Watch - Multicolor - Overstock - 19484704
Amazon.com: Garmin 010-02174-01 Vivoactive 4, GPS Smartwatch, Features Music, Body Energy Monitoring, Animated Workouts and More, Silver with Gray Band (Refurbished) : Electronics